On the north end of H Street, there's a stretch of Palm Square at 1025 North H St. where a building used to stand and nothing has replaced it. Part of the shopping center was torn down in 2022 and 2023 to make room for a larger commercial building, and that building was never built. A few hundred feet away, the old Big Lots building has been busy since August with a grocery store.
Between them, those two spots sum up the corridor right now. The grocery store is open, the newly approved projects are still plans, and the empty lot at 1025 has been approved once before.
The lot that was supposed to open in November 2023
In December 2022 the City of Lompoc put out a press release called "Major Retail Stores Coming To Lompoc." It named three stores. Big Lots had just received its certificate of occupancy at 1009 North H St. and was open. The Planning Commission had approved a 27,000-square-foot Smart & Final at 1025 North H St., with demolition of a 13,800-square-foot multi-tenant building to clear the site, and an expected opening in November 2023. An Old Navy was under review at 725 North H St.
Here's how those three turned out:
| Store in the Dec. 2022 release | Address | What happened |
|---|---|---|
| Big Lots | 1009 North H St. | Opened in late 2022; the Lompoc closure was announced in July 2024 |
| Smart & Final | 1025 North H St. | Permit was ready by April 2024, but the applicant put the project on hold |
| Old Navy | 725 North H St. | Opened Saturday, Oct. 28, 2023 |
In April 2024, KSBY reported that the Smart & Final building permit was ready to go and that the applicant had chosen to "hold" the project. Smart & Final didn't respond to the station, and the city didn't explain further. No groundbreaking ever followed. Three years after the projected opening, the site is still the empty part of Palm Square.
Later that year, the store that had opened also left. Noozhawk reported in July 2024 that the Lompoc Big Lots was on the chain's closure list as the company dealt with financial trouble. Of the three stores the city announced in 2022, Old Navy is the only one still in business.
What actually opened in the Big Lots building
The second try at 1009 North H St. has a different backer. Spencer's Fresh Markets is a family-owned chain run by John and Beatrice Spencer. It opened in the old Big Lots on Wednesday, Aug. 19, 2026. According to the Lompoc Record, the store is 31,000 square feet and is the largest of the company's three markets. John Spencer called it the new flagship that future stores will be modeled on.
The chain is older than it looks from H Street. The first Spencer's opened Sept. 30, 1996, on Orcutt Road in Santa Maria, and a Morro Bay store on Main Street followed in 1999. Lompoc is the first new location in more than 25 years, and there's a family tie. Beatrice Spencer grew up in Lompoc. Noozhawk reported that John Spencer said the project took more than a year, after the shopping center's owner reached out to him, and that the store had 80 employees at opening.
Here are the practical details if you haven't been in yet:
- Address and hours: 1009 North H St., open daily 7 a.m. to 10 p.m.
- Phone: 805-819-0693, which is also the Lompoc number listed for deli orders.
- The counter to know: John Spencer told the Lompoc Record his favorite feature is "without a doubt, the service deli."
- Meat: Harris Ranch beef, which Spencer told Noozhawk is still cut "the old-fashioned way."
- Thanksgiving: The chain's meat department page says Diestel turkeys are available for Thanksgiving and Christmas and that its seasoned standing rib roast can be ordered ahead for the holidays. It doesn't list a 2026 order deadline, so call the Lompoc store to check.
- Neighbors: Goodwill and Planet Fitness share the center.
The Spencers also told the Lompoc Record they plan tri-tip barbecues and other store events, as they hold at their other markets. No schedule has been posted yet.
Chick-fil-A is one step short of where Smart & Final stopped
Now back to that empty lot. On June 10, 2026, the Lompoc Planning Commission voted 4-0-1 to approve Chick-fil-A at 1025 North H St. It's the same address and the same 2.52 acres that were approved for Smart & Final in 2022. This plan is far smaller, though. It calls for a 4,847-square-foot restaurant with dual drive-thru lanes, indoor dining, an indoor play area and outdoor seating. That's less than a fifth of the 27,000-square-foot store once planned for the site. The Santa Maria Times reported the proposed hours as 5:30 a.m. to 11 p.m. Monday through Saturday, closed Sundays.
Palm Square owner Alan Gottlieb told commissioners his team has been working with Chick-fil-A since March 2025. He described the restaurant as part of a broader refresh of the center that includes Spencer's. Spencer's has since opened, which makes it the first finished piece of that refresh.
The restaurant is not finished yet. When KSBY reported on the approvals on July 1, the city said Chick-fil-A had submitted grading and building permit applications and was in plan check. No construction timeline had been announced. Smart & Final got one step further than that by April 2024, with approvals in hand and a permit ready, and it still didn't get built.
The two projects differ in one way. Smart & Final's plan needed an existing building torn down first. Chick-fil-A is planned as a standalone building on ground that's already cleared. The lot is ready to build on. The decision to build hasn't been made public yet.
Across the street, the theater block is next in line
The same night, the commission approved a second project on the other side of H Street. It's a new Toyota of Lompoc location at 1036 North H St., in the Northside Shopping Center. The plan calls for a 34,661-square-foot building with a two-story showroom, 12 service bays, and a car wash and detailing area. City officials told KSBY it would be a second, larger Toyota location, and the existing dealership on Ocean Avenue would stay.
The dealership would replace the Gemini Twin Theater, built in 1972 and long vacant, and the building that used to house Alfie's Fish and Chips. Alfie's itself didn't close. Its owners moved the restaurant to 610 North H St. in November 2019, according to the Santa Ynez Valley News. So only the old building at 1036 would come down, and the fish and chips stay on H Street.
Toyota is one step behind Chick-fil-A. As of KSBY's July report, it hadn't yet submitted grading and building permit applications.
How to tell when the next one is real
Smart & Final had a Planning Commission approval and a ready permit, and the lot stayed empty. Here are the steps each north H Street project has reached, as reported by KSBY and the city:
- Planning Commission approval. Smart & Final reached it in 2022. Chick-fil-A and Toyota reached it in June 2026.
- Building permit applications submitted. Chick-fil-A had filed by July 2026. Toyota hadn't.
- Plan check finished and permit ready. Smart & Final got this far by April 2024 and then stopped.
- Construction starts on site. This is the step neither 2026 project has publicly reached.
- Doors open. Spencer's opened Aug. 19, 2026, and Old Navy opened Oct. 28, 2023.
City spokesperson Emily Pruitt told KSBY that neither project needs to go before the City Council, so the next public steps are permits and construction crews. When crews show up at 1025 North H St., that will be the first time anything has been built on that lot since it was cleared in 2022 and 2023.
At Hinkens Group, we drive H Street every week too, and we keep track of what's actually getting built along it. If you own a home or rental near the north end of H Street and want to know how these changes might affect its value, ask us for a home valuation. We'll walk you through recent sales near Palm Square and the Northside Shopping Center and tell you what we're seeing on the street.