Buellton is changing the housing on Avenue of the Flags in an unusual order. The city has already voted to end long-term living in the corridor's motels, and that rule is now in court. The apartment buildings meant to give the Avenue a residential future are mostly approvals and applications. The one new apartment complex that has opened is about a mile away on McMurray Road, and every unit in it is income-restricted.
That gap matters if you're weighing a Buellton rental, a duplex near the corridor, or a home a few blocks off the Avenue. New market-rate rental supply on Avenue of the Flags is further off than the city's project list suggests.
The 22 units with a court date
In March 2026 the Buellton City Council adopted Ordinance No. 26-03 on a 4-0 vote. It requires motels along the Avenue of the Flags corridor to phase out long-term residential occupancy and limit stays to 30 consecutive days or fewer. Santa Ynez Valley News reported that city officials describe the ordinance as carrying out long-standing General Plan policy and the 2017 Avenue of Flags Specific Plan, which aim to restore the corridor's visitor-serving commercial character.
The same report says the city worked with the California Department of Housing and Community Development while drafting the rule.
On paper the ordinance covers several properties. In practice it falls mostly on one. According to the Santa Maria Times, Red Rose Court is a historic landmark, another motel is scheduled for demolition, and a third has two long-term units. The 22-unit Farmhouse Motel carries almost all of the impact. The motel's owner told the Santa Maria Sun that average monthly rents there run between $900 and $1,350.
The ordinance took effect April 25, and its 180-day compliance period ran out October 22. The owner sued the city and filed a motion asking Santa Barbara County Superior Court to pause enforcement against the Farmhouse while the case goes forward. That motion is set for a December 3 hearing in Department 4 at the Santa Maria courthouse, case No. 26CV03170. The Santa Maria Times reported that the city turned down two settlement proposals, including a five-year staged conversion.
The owner said all 22 units were still filled as of September 15, and the next decision belongs to a judge. The corridor's existing low-rent housing is being phased out first. What follows is a list of what is supposed to replace it, and how far along each piece is.
The building that opened is not on the Avenue
The new housing city staff have pointed to as potential replacement for displaced motel residents is Buellton Garden Apartments at 10 McMurray Road. It was developed by People's Self-Help Housing. The city's September 25, 2026 project list still showed it in final inspections, but the People's Self-Help Housing property page now describes it as open and accepting move-ins once applications are approved.
All 89 units serve households earning at or below 50 percent of Area Median Income, and 24 are set aside for agricultural worker households earning 30 to 50 percent of AMI. That is real new housing and a large addition for a town Buellton's size. It also serves a defined, income-qualified pool of renters. It does not add market-rate units competing for the household that would otherwise rent a duplex or a three-bedroom house in town.
The city has done a smaller version of this before. Fourteen households from Avenue of the Flags motels moved to the Polo Village affordable housing project in spring 2025, according to Santa Ynez Valley News. Per the Santa Maria Times, the motel's owner said in September that seven Farmhouse tenants had moved into newer affordable housing and that vacancies were being filled right away.
Approved in 2020 and 2022, with no construction drawings yet
The corridor's two largest apartment projects have held their approvals for years. Here is where they stood on the city's September 25, 2026 Current Major Projects Listing, next to everything else that would add homes along or near the Avenue.
| Project | Address | Homes | Stage as of fall 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buellton Garden Apartments | 10 McMurray Road | 89 income-restricted | Open, accepting move-ins |
| Central Ave Duplexes & ADUs | 430 & 440 Central Ave | 4 units plus 2 ADUs | Under construction |
| Creekside Village | 480 Avenue of Flags | 61 apartments plus 3 live/work | Approved, no construction drawings |
| The 518 | 518 Avenue of Flags | 44 apartments plus 4 live/work | Approved, no construction drawings |
| 560 Avenue of Flags | Vacant lot next to Farmhouse Motel | 26 apartments | In review, resubmittal needed |
| 545 Avenue of Flags | Feedstore building site | 24 apartments | Application incomplete |
| 410 Central Ave | 410 Central Ave | 6 units | Conceptual review, no formal application |
Creekside Village received its Final Development Plan approval on October 29, 2020, and its development agreement on November 12, 2020. The city's 2020 staff report calls its apartments rental units. Buellton's 2025 General Plan Housing Element says the project stalled during the COVID pandemic and that the developer intends to complete it within the 2023 to 2031 planning cycle.
The 518's current Final Development Plan was approved March 24, 2022, and its development agreement on April 14, 2022. Later in 2022, the applicant asked to pay in-lieu affordable housing fees instead of building affordable units on site. A city staff report tied that request to rising development costs, thin project margins and difficulty getting financing.
The council approved modifications to both projects in November 2024 and amendments to their development plans in December 2024. As of September 2026, neither had submitted construction drawings. A Santa Maria Times look at the city's pipeline lists financing, permitting, market conditions and design revisions as the reasons approved projects can sit.
Together these two projects account for 105 apartments and 7 live/work units, which is most of the Avenue's planned new housing. Neither has reached the step that comes before a building permit.
The newest proposals, including one from the motel's owner
Two newer Avenue of the Flags applications arrived this fall. City staff have flagged both as incomplete.
At 560 Avenue of Flags, a vacant 0.7-acre lot between Hotel Hygge and the Farmhouse Motel, a property owner is proposing a four-story mixed-use building. It would have 2,800 square feet of ground-floor commercial space and 26 apartments: 22 at market rate, two for moderate-income households and two for very-low-income households. The city's project page shows the application submitted September 18 and reviewed by the Planning Commission October 15. The October staff report said an incomplete letter was scheduled to go out October 16 and that the applicant would need to resubmit before a public hearing.
Across the street at 545 Avenue of Flags, the Farmhouse Motel's owner is the applicant. His plan would renovate the barn-style Buellton Feedstore as commercial space and add 24 apartments in two 12-unit, three-story buildings on either side of it. According to the city's project page, the application was submitted October 7, reviewed by the Planning Commission November 5 and sent an incomplete letter November 6.
So the same corridor has a motel owner in court over long-term occupancy at one address while applying to build apartments at another. That fits the Specific Plan's direction. The city wants homes on the Avenue in purpose-built mixed-use buildings and wants its motels operating as motels.
Reading the city's list by stage
Buellton's project list sorts every proposal into the same five buckets, and those buckets are the most useful timeline a buyer or landlord has. Running from furthest out to closest:
- Conceptual review. No formal application yet. 410 Central Ave is here.
- Applications in process. The project is in planning review and has no approval decision yet. 560 and 545 Avenue of Flags are here, and staff have flagged both applications as incomplete.
- Approved, no construction drawings submitted. The land use permits exist, but the developer hasn't started the building plan check. Creekside Village and The 518 have been here since their 2024 modifications.
- Construction plans review. Grading or building permits are pending. No Avenue of the Flags housing project is at this stage.
- Under construction or recently completed. The Central Avenue duplexes and ADUs, plus Buellton Garden.
Read that way, the corridor's new market-rate apartments are at least one full permitting stage away from a shovel. Submitting construction drawings is the step that starts a project's path toward a building permit.
For a landlord with a rental in Buellton, that means the corridor isn't about to add a wave of competing market-rate units. Buellton Garden serves a separate income-qualified pool, and the Avenue's larger entitlements haven't entered plan check. For a buyer looking at a home near the Avenue, the street's future density is approved but has no construction dates yet. Watch the next quarterly project list for Creekside Village or The 518 moving into construction plans review. That would be the first sign of a construction timeline.
Quick answers
Is Buellton Garden Apartments open? Yes. People's Self-Help Housing lists the 10 McMurray Road property as open and accepting move-ins for income-qualified households.
When is the Farmhouse Motel hearing? A judge is scheduled to hear the request to pause enforcement on December 3.
This post is general information about local rules and projects, not legal, tax or financial advice. If you own or plan to buy property affected by the ordinance, check your own situation with an attorney or other qualified professional.
If you own a rental in Buellton or are thinking about buying one near Avenue of the Flags, we follow the city's project list and the rental market every quarter. Hinkens Group can tell you what your property is worth today and what the corridor's pipeline means for your rent. Ask us for a home valuation and we'll go through it with you.